By the middle of the 20th century, life had become hard for St. Andrew's. Increasing numbers of people were moving to the suburbs and the downtown core of Toronto was giving way to offices and warehouses. Many times the congregation considered leaving its downtown location for more promising parts of the city, but each time the congregation decided that St. Andrew's witness belonged at King and Simcoe Streets.
The rebirth of downtown Toronto as a place to live in the 1970's confirmed that St. Andrew's decision to stay was right. While it is surrounded by the towers of financial institutions, hotels, theatres, concert halls, the Rogers Centre and the Convention Centre, there are also many people in new apartments and condos—and many homeless needing food and shelter. Once again St. Andrew's is taking its place in ministry to a growing city.